Connect with us

National

Delhi HC dismisses plea demanding SC Collegium disclose reasons for rejection

Published

on

Delhi HC dismisses plea demanding SC Collegium disclose reasons for rejection

New Delhi, July 4 (IANS) The Delhi High Court has dismissed an appeal seeking directions to the Supreme Court Collegium to disclose reasons for rejecting recommendations forwarded by the HC Collegium for appointment of judges.

A Division Bench presided over by Acting Chief Justice Manmohan said, “The law with respect to appointment of Judges to the Supreme Court and the High Courts is well-settled. The Supreme Court has repeatedly drawn a distinction between eligibility and suitability of a person to be appointed as a Judge of the High Court. Eligibility is an objective factor which is determined by applying the parameters or qualifications specified in Article 217(2), whereas, fitness and suitability of a person is evaluated in the consultative process.”

Earlier on May 27, a single-judge Bench had dismissed the writ petition filed by the appellant with costs, on the grounds that he had no locus standi to maintain the plea.

In his appeal, the appellant claimed that he has locus to file the writ petition as his cases have been pending in courts due to lack of appointment of judges, adding that vacancy of judges in High Courts, affects the functioning of the District Courts.

ALSO READ:  Kerala: CPI-M leader’s close aides harass pregnant woman, MLA denies allegations

“This court finds that the learned Single Judge has correctly noted that vacancies in High Court have no bearing on the pendency of cases in the District Courts. In fact, by the end of this year, the actual strength of the District judiciary is virtually going to be at par with its sanctioned strength. Consequently, the learned Single Judge has rightly held that the appellant has no locus to file the writ petition,” held the Division Bench, also comprising Justice Tushar Rao Gedela.

The appeal said that the SC Collegium in 2023 rejected 35.29 per cent of the recommendations forwarded by the HC Collegium regarding elevation of judges, whereas in the year 2021, the rejection rate was only 4.38 per cent, adding that the apex court Collegium should provide reasons to the High Court Collegium for rejecting its recommendations.

In its verdict, the Delhi High Court said that the appellant’s contention regarding “rejection” by the SC Collegium is misconceived as he has failed to understand that the appointment of a Judge to constitutional courts is an integrated, consultative and non-adversarial process, which cannot be challenged in court of law except on the ground of want of consultation with the named constitutional functionaries or lack of any condition of eligibility in the case of an appointment, or of a transfer being made without the recommendation of the Chief Justice of India.

ALSO READ:  Spokesman Kunal Ghosh turns rebel, drops Trinamool identity from social media profile

Further, publication of reasons for rejection will be detrimental to the interests and standing of people whose names have been recommended by the High Courts, as the Collegium deliberates and decides on the basis of information which is private to the individual being considered.

Such information, if made public, will have the effect of stifling the appointment process, the Delhi High Court said.

Dismissing the appeal, it asked the appellant to file an application for early hearing in his matters on the judicial side if he believes that his matters have been delayed.

–IANS

pds/rad

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

National

Schools in Delhi to remain closed on Thursday as heavy rainfall lashes city

Published

on

By

Schools in Delhi to remain closed on Thursday as heavy rainfall lashes city

Schools in Delhi to remain closed on Thursday as heavy rainfall lashes city

New Delhi, July 31 (IANS) Delhi Education Minister Atishi on Wednesday announced that all schools in the national capital — government and private — will remain closed on Thursday as heavy rains lashed the city and its peripherals, leading to waterlogging in many areas while spelling troubles for commuters.

Most parts of Delhi-NCR on Wednesday evening received heavy rainfall with roads getting flooded gradually, prompting people to run for cover as the traffic moved at snail’s pace in several areas.

In a post on X, Atishi wrote: “In light of very heavy rainfall today evening and forecast of heavy rainfall tomorrow, all schools – government and private – will remain closed tomorrow.”

Meanwhile, the India Meteorological Department (IMD) said that clouds have converged over the national capital from all four sectors, as it issued an advisory urging Delhi residents to avoid going out if not necessary.

“Clouds have converged over Delhi from all 4 sectors. Widespread Light/Moderate Rainfall with isolated Intense to very intense spell (3-5cm/hr) likely over Delhi during next 2 hours,” the IMD posted on X on Wednesday evening.

ALSO READ:  'All Indian students safe, situation normal in Bishkek'

It has also forecast that rainy conditions will continue in the national capital till August 5.

As per the IMD, Mayur Vihar in East Delhi recorded 119 mm of rain between 8.30 a.m. and 8.30 p.m. on Wednesday, while 118 mm of rain was recorded by the National Centre For Medium Range Weather Forecasting in Noida.

Many airlines, including IndiGo, Air India, Vistara, and SpiceJet, have issued advisories about flights getting diverted and asking passengers to leave for airports early and keep checking the status of their flights.

Delhi Lt Governor V.K. Saxena has directed all the concerned officials to remain on alert and address issues in the waterlogging-prone areas, including areas where coaching centres are located.

“Have cautioned all officers to remain alert in light of the ongoing heavy downpour in Delhi. Apart from ensuring minimum inconvenience to people in general, they are advised to specifically address issues at sites prone to waterlogging, including coaching centres,” the L-G said in a post on X.

ALSO READ:  ED uncovers scams involving Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister's close associates: Sources

–IANS

pgh/

Continue Reading

National

Rohingyas pose threat of demographic invasion: Himanta Biswa Sarma

Published

on

By

Rohingyas pose threat of demographic invasion: Himanta Biswa Sarma

Rohingyas pose threat of demographic invasion: Himanta Biswa Sarma

Guwahati, July 31 (IANS) Slamming the West Bengal and Jharkhand governments on the Rohingya infiltration issue, Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma on Wednesday said that the instances of Rohingyas entering eastern India have significantly increased, posing a serious threat of demographic invasion.

The Assam Chief Minister said that illegal immigration by Rohingyas is a big problem for the security of the country.

“The system of West Bengal to curb infiltration is weak. I request the Central government to resolve this issue as soon as possible,” Sarma told the media.

He said that recently, the Tripura Police have arrested a large number of Rohingyas. Last year, the Assam Police also busted a Rohingya infiltration network – a matter which was also investigated by the NIA.

Sarma said that the Centre should take up the issue of Rohingyas with the West Bengal government in an urgent manner.

“Demographic changes in several states in eastern and northern India are happening which would come as shocking news once a census is conducted. Due to the appeasement policies, we are not able to control it and Indian states are suffering… the entire country is suffering.

ALSO READ:  Telangana Cabinet approves vote-on-account Budget

“The incumbent West Bengal government is very soft about infiltration despite demography changing in Bengal,” Sarma said, adding that in the 2024 and 2019 voter lists, the change of demography is very visible.

“Due to our constant steps and close monitoring, Assam is no longer a safe haven for illegal immigrants. However, West Bengal and Jharkhand are silent on the issue,” Sarma said.

Suggesting steps similar to those taken by Tripura against the infiltration, the Assam Chief Minister said that if the infiltration does not stop now, the entire country would face a demographic invasion.

“Rohingyas are continuously coming to India through the India-Bangladesh border and many states are already suffering from the demographic invasion.”

Referring to West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee’s recent statement that the state would provide shelter to those coming from Bangladesh, the Assam Chief Minister said that the neighbouring country has not even endorsed such a statement.

Meanwhile, over the last two-and-a-half months, more than 155 Bangladeshi nationals and 32 Rohingyas have been apprehended by the Government Railway Police, Border Security Force and Tripura Police from the Agartala railway station and various other places in Tripura after they illegally entered India.

ALSO READ:  Kerala: CPI-M leader’s close aides harass pregnant woman, MLA denies allegations

–IANS

sc/pgh

Continue Reading

National

New Rajasthan BJP chief Madan Rathore to assume charge on August 3

Published

on

By

New Rajasthan BJP chief Madan Rathore to assume charge on August 3

New Rajasthan BJP chief Madan Rathore to assume charge on August 3

Jaipur, July 31 (IANS) Rajasthan BJP convened a meeting on Wednesday under the leadership of state co-in-charge Vijaya Rahatkar to discuss the arrangements for the programme in which newly-appointed state BJP chief Madan Rathore will assume charge.

Rahatkar said that at 10 a.m. on August 3, Madan Rathore will assume charge as state BJP chief at a grand ceremony in the presence of Chief Minister Bhajanlal Sharma, Cabinet ministers, all the Union ministers from Rajasthan, along with party MPs, MLAs, and senior officials.

After taking charge, Rathore will address a special meeting of state officials, and district presidents, among others, he said.

Rahatkar also said that grand decorations will be put up in Jaipur for the ceremony, along with the illumination of the state BJP headquarters here.

A total of 2,000 BJP workers will welcome Madan Rathore with a bike rally from the Jaipur airport to the BJP office.

–IANS

arc/arm

ALSO READ:  Kerala: CPI-M leader’s close aides harass pregnant woman, MLA denies allegations
Continue Reading

National

Wayanad tragedy: Contributions flow into Kerala CM's Disaster Relief Fund

Published

on

By

Wayanad tragedy: Contributions flow into Kerala CM's Disaster Relief Fund

Wayanad tragedy: Contributions flow into Kerala CM's Disaster Relief Fund

Thiruvananthapuram, July 31 (IANS) In the wake of the Wayanad landslide tragedy, Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan on Wednesday said that contributions to the CM’s Disaster Relief Fund are welcome and all those who can help should do so for a noble cause.

He said among those who have already contributed include Adani Group Chairperson Gautam Adani, Lulu Group Chairman M.K. Yusuf Ali, Dubai-based businessman Ravi Pillai, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin, Tamil actor Vikram, and the Dalai Lama Trust.

“All the Kerala ministers have agreed to contribute their one month’s salary. I call upon all those who can, to contribute,” Vijayan added.

Adani Group Chairperson Gautam Adani, in an X post, said: “Deeply saddened by the tragic loss of life in Wayanad. My heart goes out to the affected families. The Adani Group stands in solidarity with Kerala during this difficult time. We humbly extend our support with a contribution of Rs 5 crore to the Kerala Chief Minister’s Distress Relief Fund.”

ALSO READ:  Assam: Six-time MLA Bharat Chandra Narah quits Congress (Ld)

The death toll has now reached 205 while around 200 people are currently reported missing. Around 7,000 people have been evacuated safely in around 50 relief camps.

Meanwhile, hundreds of defence personnel and from several other agencies are engaged in rescue and relief operations in the four worst affected landslide areas of Wayanad district — Churalpara, Velarimala, Mundakayil and Pothukalu.

The death toll is set to rise further as more bodies trapped under debris are being recovered.

–IANS

sg/khz/vd

Continue Reading

National

10 flights diverted after rain batters Delhi-NCR; IMD issues red alert for next 24 hrs

Published

on

By

10 flights diverted after rain batters Delhi-NCR; IMD issues red alert for next 24 hrs

10 flights diverted after rain batters Delhi-NCR; IMD issues red alert for next 24 hrs

New Delhi, July 31 (IANS) As many as 10 flights headed to Delhi were diverted after heavy rain lashed Delhi-NCR on Wednesday evening, prompting the India Meteorological Department (IMD) to issue a ‘red alert’ in the national capital for the next 24 hours.

The incessant rain led to waterlogging in several parts of Delhi -NCR, as traffic came to a standstill in many areas.

The IMD said that clouds have converged over the national capital from all four sectors, as it issued an advisory urging Delhi residents to avoid going out if not necessary.

“Clouds have converged over Delhi from all 4 sectors. Widespread Light/Moderate Rainfall with isolated Intense to very intense Spell (3-5cm/hr) likely over Delhi during next 2 hours,” the weather office said in a post on X on Wednesday evening.

The IMD has also forecast that rainy conditions will continue in the national capital till August 5.

As per the IMD, Mayur Vihar in East Delhi recorded 119 mm of rain between 8.30 a.m. and 8.30 p.m. on Wednesday, while 118 mm of rain was recorded by the National Centre For Medium Range Weather Forecasting in Noida.

ALSO READ:  'All Indian students safe, situation normal in Bishkek'

Many airlines, including IndiGo, Air India, Vistara, and SpiceJet, have issued advisories about flights getting diverted and asking passengers to leave for airports early and keep checking the status of their flights.

In a post on X, IndiGo said, “The rain gods have decided to shower #Delhi with their blessings tonight. As a result, we’re expecting heavy rainfall throughout the night. Check your flight status.”

Meanwhile, Delhi Lieutenant Governor V.K. Saxena has directed all the concerned officials to remain on alert and address issues in the waterlogging-prone areas, including areas where coaching centres are located.

“Have cautioned all officers to remain alert in light of the ongoing heavy downpour in Delhi. Apart from ensuring minimum inconvenience to people in general, they are advised to specifically address issues at sites prone to waterlogging, including coaching centres,” the L-G said in a post on X.

–IANS

arm/

Continue Reading

Trending